Three Cries
A dramatic monologue based on 1 Samuel 4
Young Benjamin ran in fear.
The things he had seen in battle that day had torn deeply at his heart. The Philistines had fought like madmen. One by one, Benjamin had watched his brothers, cousins and friends cut down in the fields. Those who survived had turned and fled from the battlefield.
As Benjamin stumbled over the rocks on the road to Shiloh, tears soaked his face.
How could this happen?
This was supposed to be our great victory!
After the first defeat at Aphek, where four thousand Israelites had died, everyone's spirits had been lifted when the Ark of the Covenant arrived in the camp the evening before. Flanked by the high priest's sons, Hophni and Phinehas, the Ark had entered the camp to a deafening roar.
Benjamin could still hear it.
The great cry of triumph had echoed across the valley toward the Philistine camp. Men laughed, cheered, embraced one another and shouted until the ground seemed to shake beneath their feet.
"Now God will give us victory!"
"No army can stand against us now!"
Surely the Philistines would be defeated.
Surely God would fight for Israel.
But no.
Disaster had come.
Defeat had come.
Benjamin collapsed beside the road to Shiloh and tore his clothes. Overwhelmed with shame and grief, he scooped up dust and threw it upon his head.
How could he bear the news of defeat?
How could he tell the people that the Ark of God had been captured by their enemies?
Worse still, how could he tell them that Hophni and Phinehas, the sons of the high priest, were dead?
Benjamin staggered to his feet.
He had to carry the news.
Who knew what lay ahead for Israel now?
Driven on, he forced his weary legs down the road.
It was late in the day when Benjamin reached the first houses of Shiloh.
His face was drawn with exhaustion and sorrow. Tears had carved muddy streaks across his dust-covered cheeks.
House after house, the news spread.
An ever-increasing wail of grief rose through the town until Benjamin scarcely needed to speak. His torn clothes, dust-covered head and haunted eyes told the story.
People stood in the streets in stunned disbelief.
Women wept. Men lowered their heads.
Neighbours clung to one another.
Then Benjamin saw Eli.
The old, heavy-set priest sat on a chair by the gate. Though blind and frail, he could hear the cries and mourning rising from nearby.
Benjamin's heart sank.
Oh, to be the bearer of such news.
The old priest turned his head towards the sound of approaching footsteps.
"What is it, my son?" he asked.
Benjamin swallowed hard.
"We are badly defeated, holy one. The army has fled before the Philistines. Many have fallen."
Eli's face tightened.
"And your sons..." Benjamin continued quietly. "Hophni and Phinehas are dead."
For a moment there was silence.
Then Eli cried out,
"The Ark of God! What has happened to the Ark?"
Benjamin lowered his head.
"Gone," he replied. "Captured by the enemy."
A gasp escaped Eli's lips.
He toppled backwards from his chair beside the gate. Benjamin rushed forward, but it was too late.
The old priest's neck was broken.
Eli was dead.
Our priest. Our judge. Gone.
And still the cries of Shiloh echoed through the streets.
Yet another cry came from a nearby house that day.
It was the cry of a baby just born.
The child arrived as death and sorrow swept through Israel.
His father, Phinehas, was dead.
His grandfather, Eli, was dead.
The Ark of God was gone.
And his mother was dying.
With her final breath she named her son:
"Ichabod."
Then she died.
Benjamin stood silently and whispered the name to himself.
"Ichabod."
"The glory has departed."
The glory has departed from Israel.
Benjamin looked towards the darkening sky.
Do we have a future?
The Ark is gone.
What do we trust in now?
Where is God?
Is there any hope left?
Who will care for this baby?
Who hears our cries now?
Silence.
The first cry had been a cry of confidence.
The second cry had been a cry of grief.
The third cry had been a cry of despair.
But the greatest question still remained:
We might ask like Benjamin...
"Who hears our cries now?"
Perhaps you've asked that question yourself.
Maybe in illness.
Maybe in grief.
Maybe in disappointment.
Maybe when prayers seemed unanswered.
The people of Israel looked around and concluded that everything was lost. The Ark was gone, the priest was dead, and a child was given the name Ichabod - "the glory has departed."
But appearances can be deceptive.
Even when God's people lose what they most treasure, God Himself has not gone anywhere.
And that is the great lesson of 1 Samuel chapter 4.
(©Don Stott, Nov.2026)
Would you like to listen to the original song I wrote based on this story and the Bible passage? Check out this QR code below and it will give you the link to the YouTube version of the song.
RSS Feed